products file · Updated October 29, 2026
Augusta Segregated vs Commingled Storage: What the Extra $50 a Year Buys
By the Augusta Precious Metals Review editorial team
TL;DR
Segregated storage costs $160 a year and pooled $110 at Delaware Depository via Equity Trust: $500 more over 10 years. Silver can only be pooled there.
Advertising disclosure: if you request Augusta's information kit through a link on this page, this site may receive compensation from Augusta Precious Metals. That relationship never changes a finding on this site. How compensation works here.
Research, not advice. Read the full notice
Nothing below has been tailored to your circumstances, and none of it counts as investment guidance, tax counsel, or a retirement plan. Money placed in bullion or in a metals-backed retirement account can be lost: principal carries no protection, positions are often slow to sell, dealers price above spot, vault and insurance bills recur annually, and withdrawing early or the wrong way hands the IRS a penalty. What metals did in any prior stretch says nothing dependable about what comes next. Speak with a fiduciary advisor, and with whoever prepares your taxes, before you open a gold IRA, move a 401(k) balance, or place an order for metal. Whoever writes here researches this industry independently and holds no advisory license: no CFP, no CFA, no broker-dealer registration.
Segregated storage for an Augusta IRA costs $160 a year and commingled storage costs $110, both flat, on Equity Trust’s fee schedule read October 29, 2026. The $50 gap adds up to $500 over 10 years and $1,000 over 20. Segregation returns the exact pieces you deposited. Commingled storage returns the same weight and type of metal, possibly of a different brand, year or condition. At Delaware Depository, silver can only be commingled.
This page covers the decision between the two storage types and the cost math behind it. Every figure names the document it came from. Where a company prints nothing, we say so. What an Augusta customer gets for storage, site by site and fee by fee, is on the storage options page.
Key figures at a glance
| Item | Commingled (non-segregated) | Segregated | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Annual storage fee | $110, flat | $160, flat | Equity Trust fee schedule FS-0004-05 Rev. 081726 |
| How metal is grouped | By product, with other customers’ identical product | By customer, in the customer’s own container | delawaredepository.com/faqs/ |
| What you get back | Weight and general type; may not be the same brand, year or condition | The exact metals your dealer sent | Equity Trust depository options document ET-0075-43 |
| Gold, platinum, palladium at Delaware Depository | Available | Available | Equity Trust ET-0075-43 |
| Silver at Delaware Depository | All silver | Not offered, except 1,000-oz bars, which are always segregated | Equity Trust ET-0075-43 |
| Account fees, year one | $285 | $335 | Equity Trust FS-0004-05; our arithmetic |
| Account fees, each year after | $235 | $285 | Equity Trust FS-0004-05; our arithmetic |
| 10-year difference | $500 more | Our arithmetic, nominal, no waiver | |
| 20-year difference | $1,000 more | Our arithmetic, nominal, no waiver | |
| Typical use, per the depository | Fungible products | Special year, specific brand, numismatic or sentimental products | delawaredepository.com/faqs/ |
What does each storage type mean, in the depository’s own words?
Three documents define the two types. They agree on the core and differ on one detail that matters at withdrawal.
Delaware Depository. Its FAQ describes non-segregated storage, which it calls “comingled”, as metal “allocated on our system and physically separated by product.” It gives an example: “Customers who own a product such as 1-oz. Gold American Eagles will have their 1-oz. Gold American Eagles stored with other customers’ 1-oz. Gold American Eagles. Non-segregated storage is the preferred choice for fungible products.”
For segregated storage, the same FAQ says metal is “allocated on our system and physically separated by customer. Customers who choose segregated storage receive their own container where the metal is separate and apart from all other metal. The exact material deposited is returned upon withdrawal.”
Equity Trust. The custodian’s depository options document, ET-0075-43, describes segregated metal as held “in an Equity Trust storage area” and “marked and stored with your name”, and says “you will receive the exact metals that your precious metals dealer sent to the depository”. Non-segregated metal “will be commingled with other Equity Trust clients’ metals”, and “you will receive the weight and general type (silver, gold, etc.) of metals you purchased but may not receive the same brand, year, or condition of the metals you purchased.”
Augusta. Augusta’s gold and silver storage page says: “Segregated storage keeps your specific coins or bars physically separated and identified as yours alone. What you deposit is what you get back.” Non-segregated storage “holds your metals alongside other clients’ holdings of the same type. You still own an equivalent quantity and type of metal, but not the identical physical pieces you deposited.”
The depository’s definition of pooled storage is product by product: Eagles with Eagles. Equity Trust’s wording is looser. It promises weight and general type, and it reserves the right to return a different brand, year or condition. The custodian’s document is the one tied to an Equity Trust account, so plan on its wording, not the depository’s.
Does commingled mean your metal is unallocated or lent out?
Delaware Depository says no on both counts. Its FAQ states: “Delaware Depository stores bullion on behalf of its customers and does not lend or lease metal. All bullion is fully allocated.” Its storage and transfer page adds: “At Delaware Depository, all precious metal assets are held off-balance sheet in fully allocated, individually-identified custody accounts.”

Both definitions in the FAQ begin with the same words, “allocated on our system”. Pooled metal is still assigned to your account on the depository’s records. What changes is the shelf. Your 1-oz coins share space with identical coins owned by other customers, and the records say how many of them belong to your IRA.
The storage page ties pooled storage to record-keeping: “Frequent recurring audits and independently-audited internal controls ensure that all bullion is properly accounted for.” That is the depository’s own claim. How the audits work and what an IRA owner can check are on the audit and verification page. The insurance and legal protections that apply to both types are on the vault security and insurance page.
What do you get back on withdrawal?
It depends on the storage type, and the difference only shows up when metal leaves the vault.
Segregated. The exact pieces your dealer sent, per Equity Trust. If you bought a specific year of a coin, a specific mint’s bar, or a coin in a particular graded condition, those pieces come back.
Commingled. The same weight and general type, per Equity Trust, possibly of a different brand, year or condition. Buy 1-oz gold coins of one design and year, and you could receive 1-oz gold coins that differ in year or condition. For a coin valued on its metal content alone, the metal you receive is the same. For a coin whose year or condition carries a premium, it may not be worth the same.
Withdrawal costs are the same for both types on Equity Trust’s fee schedule: $125 per in-kind distribution or transfer out, coin shipping and handling at cost plus $10 with a $50 minimum, and $30 per liquidation. Delaware Depository’s FAQ says withdrawals are normally processed within 24 hours. Equity Trust’s depository document says pick-ups are typically scheduled two to three weeks after a request, and that any claim on an in-kind delivery must reach Equity Trust within one business day of delivery.

If you sell the metal back through the IRA instead of taking it out, the storage type matters less. A bullion coin valued on its metal content gains nothing from being the exact piece you deposited. The pricing page covers how to get Augusta’s buyback bid in writing.
What does the extra $50 a year add up to?
The table below is our arithmetic on Equity Trust schedule FS-0004-05 Rev. 081726. It uses the $50 setup fee, the $125 annual maintenance fee and the storage line for each type. It assumes the schedule does not change, uses nominal dollars, and excludes wire fees, any waiver and the dealer’s spread on the metal.
| Period | Commingled, cumulative | Segregated, cumulative | Difference |
|---|---|---|---|
| Year 1 | $285 | $335 | $50 |
| 5 years | $1,225 | $1,475 | $250 |
| 10 years | $2,400 | $2,900 | $500 |
| 20 years | $4,750 | $5,750 | $1,000 |
Because the fee is flat, the $50 shrinks as a share of the account as the account grows. Again our arithmetic:
| Value of metal stored | Extra cost of segregation per year | 20-year extra as share of starting value |
|---|---|---|
| $50,000 (Augusta’s minimum) | 0.10% | 2.0% |
| $100,000 | 0.05% | 1.0% |
| $250,000 | 0.02% | 0.4% |
| $500,000 | 0.01% | 0.2% |
At Augusta’s $50,000 minimum, segregation costs one tenth of one percent a year. That is small. For standard bullion, it buys the right to the same pieces, and those pieces carry no extra metal.
Augusta quotes a fee waiver by phone, described on the fees page with the 10-year tables for the full fee stack. No document we read says whether that waiver covers the $160 segregated line or only the $110 line. Ask before you choose, and get the answer in writing.
Why can’t silver be segregated at Delaware Depository?
The documents do not say why. They only say that it cannot. Equity Trust’s depository options document lists Delaware Depository’s segregated option as “Yes, offered for Gold, Platinum, and Palladium only” and its non-segregated option as “Yes NOTE: All Silver is non-segregated”. A footnote adds: “1000 oz. silver bars will be segregated regardless of what choice is made upon set up”.
Delaware Depository’s own pages do not carry this limit. Its storage page says its Nevada and Delaware locations “fully accommodate the storage of gold, silver, platinum and palladium coins and bars”, and its segregated definition does not exclude any metal. The restriction appears in the Equity Trust arrangement. We do not speculate on the reason.
For an Augusta customer, the effect is direct. Silver coins and ordinary silver bars bought for the IRA are stored in pooled form at Delaware Depository, whatever the account form says. The IRA-eligible silver coins list shows which silver products qualify. A 1,000-ounce bar is the only silver product that comes back as the exact piece deposited.
Two consequences follow. First, a silver-only account has no segregation decision to make at Delaware Depository. Second, a mixed account that elects segregation gets it for the gold, platinum and palladium only. Equity Trust’s schedule prints one fee per storage type, and no document we read explains how a mixed account is billed. Its footnote adds that storage fees “may be assessed by each deposity” [sic], which does not settle it. Ask Equity Trust for the billing method in writing.
Augusta’s IRA setup and custody FAQ makes a related general point: whether a custodian and depository charge more to store silver than gold depends on the actual storage agreement and fee schedule. On Equity Trust’s flat schedule, the bulk of silver does not raise the fee.
When does segregation earn its fee?
Delaware Depository’s FAQ names the cases: “Segregated storage is a common choice for special year, specific brand, numismatic coins or sentimental products.” It describes pooled storage as “the preferred choice for fungible products.”
The FAQ explains fungibility with bars. It compares 1-oz gold bars to a stack of $20 bills: each bar carries a unique serial number, yet “they all have the same value and are interchangeable.” Larger bars are different: “Non-fungible bullion bars have a combination of four characteristics (weight, fineness, hallmark and serial number) that render each item unique.”
That gives a working test. If any piece in the order would be worth less to you when swapped for another piece of the same weight and type, segregation protects that difference. If a swap changes nothing, the $50 a year buys nothing you can sell.
| What you hold | Storage that fits | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Standard 1-oz gold bullion coins, any year | Commingled | Fungible; a like-for-like coin carries the same metal |
| Small gold bars sold on weight | Commingled | Fungible, per Delaware Depository’s own example |
| Coins bought for a specific year or mint | Segregated | Equity Trust may return a different year |
| Graded or numismatic coins | Segregated | Condition carries value, and pooled storage may not return the same condition |
| Large serial-numbered bars you want back by number | Segregated | Non-fungible, per Delaware Depository |
| Any silver at Delaware Depository | Commingled, no choice | All silver is non-segregated, except 1,000-oz bars |
| Metal you plan to take out in kind as exact pieces | Segregated | Only segregation returns the same pieces |
The middle rows lead to a harder question than storage. A coin whose year or condition carries value costs more than its metal, and that premium is paid inside a retirement account. Augusta’s premium coins program page covers what those products cost. If you find you need segregated storage, the product choice deserves the scrutiny first.
Who should pay for segregation, and who should not?
Pay the $160 if the order holds special-year, numismatic or graded coins, or serial-numbered bars you want back by number, or if you plan to take the exact pieces out in kind later. At Augusta’s $50,000 minimum, $50 a year is 0.1 percent of the account, which is a small price for keeping a premium coin’s premium intact.
Stay at $110 if the account holds standard gold bullion coins or small bars that you expect to sell back for cash. Bullion valued on its metal content gains nothing at sale from being the exact piece deposited. Over 20 years the saving is $1,000.
No choice applies to silver at Delaware Depository through Equity Trust. If an account is mostly silver, the $50 buys segregation only for the small gold share, if any.
A segregated container has one practical side effect: on a viewing visit, segregated metal can be shown as yours. Pooled metal is your share of a shelf of identical products. This is our inference from the two definitions, not a published rule of the depository. Augusta’s storage FAQ says visits need advance arrangements and may be subject to identification requirements or fees.
Does the law care which one you pick?
No rule we read requires either type. The bullion exception in 26 U.S.C. 408(m)(3)(B) requires IRA bullion to be “in the physical possession of a trustee described under subsection (a)”. Both storage types at Delaware Depository meet that test in the same way, because the metal sits at the depository under the custodian’s control either way.

A second clause causes confusion. Section 408(a)(5) says “the assets of the trust will not be commingled with other property except in a common trust fund or common investment fund.” That clause concerns IRA assets mixing with property outside the trust, such as an owner’s personal coins kept in the same safe. Pooled depository storage, where identical products owned by different IRA accounts share a shelf and are allocated by record, is a different arrangement. It is the standard option at Delaware Depository and on Equity Trust’s grid. Do not read 408(a)(5) as a ban on commingled storage.
IRS Publication 590-A lists the coins and bullion an IRA may hold and treats other collectibles as distributed in the year bought. It sets no storage-type requirement. The rules on where IRA metal may sit are on the gold IRA storage page.
Can you switch storage type later?
Equity Trust’s depository options document gives the route. It says to contact your precious metals dealer to discuss the storage options at your current storage facility, because “there may be limitations, cost changes, or other applicable information to consider,” and then to complete the Depository Change Form, which Equity Trust reviews within 1 to 3 business days.
Fee schedule FS-0004-05 lists no switch fee. Whether the depository charges a handling cost to move metal from a pooled shelf into a segregated container is not published in anything we read. The annual storage line would move from $110 to $160. For silver at Delaware Depository, there is nothing to switch to.
Do some depositories offer only segregated storage?
Yes. Equity Trust’s grid shows International Depository Services and Texas Bullion Depository as segregated only, with “No” in the non-segregated column. Texas Precious Metals Depository, which is not on Equity Trust’s list, says on its own site that all metal is fully segregated. Augusta names none of these facilities. The gold IRA storage page compares them for readers still choosing a dealer.
What the documents do not settle
- How Equity Trust bills a mixed account with segregated gold and pooled silver.
- Whether Augusta’s account paperwork pre-selects a storage type.
- Whether Equity Trust’s “storage area” at Delaware Depository is one pooled area for all its clients.
- Whether any handling charge applies to a switch from pooled to segregated storage.
- Whether Augusta’s phone-quoted fee waiver covers the $160 segregated line.
- Why silver cannot be segregated at Delaware Depository through Equity Trust.
Ask Augusta and Equity Trust each of these by email before you fund, and keep the replies with the account paperwork.
The verdict
For standard gold bullion, commingled storage at $110 a year does the job. The metal is allocated to your IRA on the depository’s records, it is not lent out, and on withdrawal you get the same weight and type back. Pay $160 only when the exact piece matters: a special year, a graded coin, a serial-numbered bar. That costs $500 over 10 years and $1,000 over 20. Silver at Delaware Depository is pooled whatever you choose, so a silver-heavy account has no reason to pay for segregation.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between segregated and commingled storage at Delaware Depository?
Delaware Depository's FAQ, read October 29, 2026, separates the two by what the metal is grouped with. In non-segregated, or commingled, storage, bullion is allocated on its system and physically separated by product, so one customer's 1-oz Gold American Eagles sit with other customers' 1-oz Gold American Eagles. In segregated storage, metal is physically separated by customer, in the customer's own container, and the exact material deposited is returned on withdrawal. Both types are allocated on the depository's records. The difference is whether your specific pieces are kept apart.
How much more does segregated storage cost for an Augusta IRA?
$50 a year. Equity Trust's fee schedule FS-0004-05 Rev. 081726, read October 29, 2026, lists $160 a year for segregated storage and $110 for non-segregated. Both are flat, so the gap stays $50 whatever the account holds. On our arithmetic, with the schedule unchanged and no waiver, that is $500 over 10 years and $1,000 over 20. Ten-year account fees come to $2,900 segregated against $2,400 non-segregated. Augusta's own FAQ quotes only the $110 line, so the $160 figure comes from the custodian's schedule.
Can Augusta customers segregate silver?
Not at Delaware Depository through Equity Trust. Equity Trust's depository options document, read October 29, 2026, shows segregated storage at Delaware Depository as offered for gold, platinum and palladium only, with the note that all silver is non-segregated. The one exception is a footnote: 1,000-ounce silver bars are segregated regardless of the choice made at setup. Silver coins and ordinary silver bars bought for an Augusta IRA are stored in pooled form. Neither document explains the reason, and we do not guess at one.
If my storage is commingled, do I get my own coins back?
Not necessarily the same pieces. Equity Trust's depository options document says non-segregated metal is commingled with other Equity Trust clients' metals, and that on withdrawal you receive the weight and general type of metal you bought but may not receive the same brand, year or condition. Delaware Depository's FAQ describes pooled storage as separated by product, which is narrower. The custodian's wording is the one in your account paperwork, so plan on Equity Trust's version. For standard bullion, a like-for-like replacement carries the same metal content.
Does commingled storage mean the depository can lend my metal?
Delaware Depository says no. Its FAQ, read October 29, 2026, states that it stores bullion on behalf of its customers, does not lend or lease metal, and that all bullion is fully allocated. Its storage page says all precious metal assets are held off-balance sheet in fully allocated, individually identified custody accounts. Commingled storage there means your product shares a shelf with identical product owned by others, while the depository's records allocate a specific quantity to your IRA. The audit and verification page on this site covers how those records are checked.
Who should pay for segregated storage?
Delaware Depository's FAQ names the usual cases: special year, specific brand, numismatic coins or sentimental products. Add serial-numbered bars you want back by number, and any plan to take the exact pieces out in kind later. For standard gold bullion coins that will be sold back for cash, segregation buys little, because one 1-oz coin of a given type carries the same metal as another. Silver cannot be segregated at Delaware Depository through Equity Trust, so the $50 buys nothing for the silver part of an account.
Does IRS law require segregated storage for a gold IRA?
No rule we read requires it. The bullion exception in 26 U.S.C. 408(m)(3)(B) requires the metal to be in the physical possession of a trustee and says nothing about separate containers. Section 408(a)(5) bars commingling trust assets with other property, but that concerns IRA assets mixing with non-IRA property, such as an owner's personal coins. Pooled depository storage, where identical products owned by different IRAs share space and are allocated by record, is the standard arrangement Equity Trust and Delaware Depository both offer.
Can I switch from commingled to segregated storage later?
Equity Trust describes a route. Its depository options document says to contact your precious metals dealer to discuss the storage options at your current facility, because there may be limitations, cost changes or other details, and then to complete a Depository Change Form, which Equity Trust reviews within 1 to 3 business days. No switch fee appears on fee schedule FS-0004-05. The annual storage line would move from $110 to $160. For silver at Delaware Depository, there is nothing to switch to.
